Posted on

Peer editing worksheet for compare and contrast essay

compare contrast essay editing rubric

INFORMATIONAL/INFORMATIVE ESSAY WRITING: COMPARE AND CONTRAST CCSS ALIGNED

Scaffold the structure of a compare and contrast essay through each stage of the writing process with this interactive notebook and flipbook resource. Students will be trained to write both in point-by-point style and block style.*********************************************************************This resource is included in the mega writing (growing) bundle:OPINION/NARRATIVE/BIOGRAPHY/INFORMATIVE COMMON CORE WRITING BUNDLE********************************************************************WHA

Writing BUNDLE – Organizing, Editing & Citing Writing, Types of Writing

This bundle includes 6 resources that teach your students how to do various types of writing, how to organize information that will be used for writing, how to cite sources of writing for a bibliography, and how to edit writing. The 7th resource offers several rubrics and checklists you can use to assess your students’ writing.✓ Please note: * If you prefer, you can purchase 2 small bundles containing 3 writing resources each HERE and HERE at 20% discounts but neither small bundle includes the

Descriptive Essay Writing Super Bundle

Descriptive Essay Writing Bundle Unit. Here is everything you will need to teach a descriptive essay aligned with the Writing Common Core Standards for grades 3-5. Included in this super bundle is: -A Steps of the Writing Process PowerPoint useful to introduce the writing process -A Descriptive Essay PowerPoint that can be used to introduce the unit -A 7 Day Lesson Plan for the teacher -An example of a completed web and blank web for students’ pre-writing -A good and bad example for students to

Immediate Feedback Essay Editing with Single-Point Rubric

Use this activity as a fast-paced check of student rough drafts, allowing the teacher to provide instant feedback on single-point rubric punch cards. The activity has options for expository and compare-contrast essays, as well as APA and MLA formatting. The single-point punch cards check everything from grammar to syntax variation to topic sentences to arguable thesis statements and more!Please note that this activity should be used AFTER students have completed at least one rough draft paragrap

The Giver Book & Movie Compare/Contrast Essay

  • Word Document File

Based on The Giver, this cumulative assignment breaks down a compare and contrast essay. Step one- using a graphic organizer, student will record information about the film and text. Step two- students will narrow down their findings and outline body paragraphs. Step three- students will outline their personal opinion. Step four- Students write their rough draft using the specific paragraph notes included (a thesis statement is also provided). Step five- students revise/edit essay using the chec

The Outsiders Book & Movie Compare/Contrast Essay

  • Word Document File

Based on The Outsiders, this cumulative assignment breaks down a compare and contrast essay. Step one- using a graphic organizer, student will record information about the film and text. Step two- students will narrow down their findings and outline body paragraphs. Step three- students will outline their personal opinion. Step four- Students write their rough draft using the specific paragraph notes included (a thesis statement is also provided). Step five- students revise/edit essay using the

Christmas Country Traditions Compare and Contrast Essay Project

Are you looking for an assignment that combines the Christmas holiday theme with research, writing, and compare and contrast standards that need covered and practiced? You are in the right place! Students will research the United States Christmas traditions and history along with one other country of their choice. They will use provided website sources if needed, find similarities and differences while researching to put on their Venn diagram, use their research to fill in the detailed outline p

Number the Stars Compare/Contrast Essay

  • Word Document File

Based on Number the Stars, this cumulative assignment breaks down a character compare and contrast essay with Annemarie Anne Frank (a link to an animate film version is included). Step one- using a graphic organizer, student will record information about the film and text. Step two- students will narrow down their findings and outline body paragraphs. Step three- students will outline their personal opinion. Step four- Students write their rough draft using the specific paragraph notes included

Peer editing worksheet for compare and contrast essay

Peer Review Checklist for Comparison Contrast (C19)

Have a sheet of paper on which you write your comments. The sheet should be labeled with your name as the reader and the name of the person who wrote the paper as the writer. Use the numbers to identify your comments.

Do not write on the person’s paper. Write only on your comment sheet. Place the comments with the paper, give the paper back to the person who wrote it, who will then return the paper to me.

After reading the first paragraph only, answer these three questions :

1. What two things are being compared?

  1. Who is the intended audience for this paper?
  2. What will be the structure and outline of the body of the paper?

Then read the rest of the paper and answer these questions. Try to answer them without looking back again at the paper for what you might have missed.

Revising Comparison-Contrast Essays

Drafting is done! You’ve bootstrapped yourself from having no idea what to write about to having a complete essay in its initial form. Congratulations! Writers often find prewriting and drafting to be the most challenging steps because they have to start with a blank page. Now you have a full page or more, so the work from here on out should be easier.

Even so, other writers hate revising and editing. They feel like they have an essay and should be done. Also, they don’t know how to make major improvements (revisions) let alone specific corrections (editing). If you are one of those writers, don’t despair. The activities in this lesson plan and the next will guide you.

Revising for Parallel Structure

Parallel structure means presenting equal ideas using the same grammatical form. If you have a paragraph defining and explaining one topic, you should have a paragraph defining and explaining the other. If you have a sentence presenting one point of comparison for one topic, you should have a sentence presenting the same point of comparison for the other topic. Parallel structure even gets down to the level of using phrases or words.

You can think of parallel structure like a teeter-totter. The idea on one side needs to balance the idea on the other side. The fulcrum (pivot) of the teeter-totter is often the word and, but, or or.

Parallel Words

Both Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X agreed about the cause of racism and injustice.

Nonparallel Words

Both Martin Luther King Jr. and “Message to the Grassroots” agreed about the cause of racism and people weren’t receiving justice.

The parallel example pairs a name with a name and a noun with a noun. The grammatical form shows readers that these ideas are equal. The nonparallel example pairs a name with a speech title and a noun with a clause. The shifts in grammatical form leave readers confused.

Parallel Clauses

People with Asperger’s syndrome have mild disabilities combined with strong intellectual talents, but people with savant syndrome have profound disabilities combined with “islands of genius.”

Nonparallel Clauses

People with Asperger’s syndrome have mild disabilities combined with strong intellectual talents, but when a savant has uncanny talents.

The parallel example pairs two independent clauses (complete sentences), each using the same structure (“People with . . . have . . . combined with . . .”). The nonparallel example pairs an independent clause with a dependent clause (incomplete thought), thereby creating confusion. What happens when a savant has uncanny talents?

When you connect three or more ideas with an and or or, each idea must have the same grammatical structure to create a parallel series.

Parallel Series

These “islands of genius” include calendar calculation, musical mimicry, and eidetic memory.

Nonparallel Series

These “islands of genius” include calendar calculation, musical mimicry, and they can draw complex maps from memory.

The parallel series connects three nouns, each with a modifier. The nonparallel series starts with the same pattern but shifts to an independent clause. This series is confusing and grammatically incorrect.

Correct nonparallel structure.

Rework each sentence below to make nonparallel elements parallel. Watch for ideas joined by and, but, or or. Make a copy of this Google doc or download a Word template.

Martin Luther King called all people to live together in peace, justice, and love we should live together in love .

King tried to stand between those who do nothing and those who believe in black nationalism when they are black nationalists .

King dreamed of a day when people would be judged not by the color of their skin but by the content of their character their character content was what they were judged by .

Those with Asperger’s syndrome often excel in math, science, or history they are interested in history .

Not all people on the autism spectrum have savant abilities, and not all people with savant abilities have autism autism with not all people with savant abilities .

Review for parallel structure.

Reread your essay, paying close attention to the grammatical structures you use to present ideas. Make sure equal ideas have the same grammatical structure. Rewrite parts as needed.

Revising to Improve Transitions

Transition words and phrases can also help you sort out comparisons and contrasts. These words signal the kinds of ideas that you are presenting at a given moment.